Wednesday, March 28, 2012

Part 3

 


Career:
After attending University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill he trained to be a medical doctor at Columbia University, Walker contracted Tuberculosis while preforming an autopsy as an intern. He spent the next several years recovering in New York. During this period he read existentialist authors and began to question human existence. Walker published his first novel, The Moviegoer in 1961. Walker continued to publish several other works including: The Last Gentleman (1966), Love in the Ruins(1971), Lancelot (1977), The Second Coming (1980), and The Thanatos Syndrome in 1987. 
Why am I here? What should I do? What/Who is God? What is the meaning of life? Throughout Percy Walker’s novel The Moviegoer, the protagonist struggles to answer all these questions. Early in the novel, there is little mention of religion. During part three Walker’s religious roots are exposed as Binx struggles with his place in society.  
            Binx’s religious opinions are expressed through his internal thoughts. While conversing with his mother, Binx explains:
            Sometimes when she mentions God, it strikes me that my mother uses him as but one of the devices that come to hand in an outrageous man’s world, to be put to work like all the rest in the one enterprise she has any use for: the canny management of the shocks of life…she has wanted everything colloquial and easy, even God” Page 142
            Binx’s mother employs God to make her life easier and understandable. As Binx describes, his mother uses religion to explain what she does not understand. The “shocks of life” refer to everything that the mother cannot explain for herself and turns to God. One of these “shocks” was the death of Duval.  After Duval’s passing the mother lost sight of the true practice of religion and uses God to make her life easy. From the description, Binx’s mother has not devoted her life to God and does not seek salvation. The mother chooses to instead use religion only when it suits her.
Unlike his mother, Binx has no desire or understanding of religion. Similar to many things in the novel, Binx does not have an opinion on the matter of religion. Binx expresses his indifference towards religion when he explains,
“My mother’s family thinks I have lost my faith and they pray for me to recover it. I don’t know what they’re talking about.” Page 145
This thought pronounces his disillusionment from faith. Binx is indifferent to the fact that other people are worried for his lack of religion. Binx openly expresses is confusion with the purpose of religion. Binx lacks the desire to acquire religion and his family’s prayers are in vain.
Later in the philosophical explanation, Binx continues to explain the depth of his disbelief. Through this description Binx appears to be proud of his unwillingness to accept God. Binx states,

            “My unbelief was invincible from the beginning. I could never make head of tail of God. The proofs God’s existence may have been true for all I know, but it didn’t make the slightest difference. If God himself appeared to me it would have changed nothing. In fact, I have only to hear the word God and a curtain comes down in my head.” Page 145
First, Binx claims his inability to make sense of God as the logic for his “unbelief”. God is not a tangible object that Binx can see and touch. Emotions prevent Binx from grasping faith in God. The fact that God is not tangible is not what prevents Binx from having faith. Binx claims even witnessing God would not change his opinions towards religion. To witness God and still disbelieve is simply denying truth. This statement enables the reader to conclude there is more to Binx’s refusal of religion than simply not believing. Binx rejects all possibility of seeking religion when he chooses to ignore any mention of God. Binx describes a “curtain” descending upon his head at the mention of God. I think Binx hides behind this curtain because he fears religion. Binx employs the curtain to separate his mind from religious interference.
 Many people find purpose through the church and God. Throughout the novel, Binx struggles to find a purpose for life. I think Binx’s inability to accept religion is the reason he cannot find a purpose in this world. Binx is enthralled with his “search” and the answer to all of his questions can be found in faith. Unfortunately, Binx’s mother is a strong religious influence and uses religion only to make life easier. 

9 comments:

  1. My question is...do you think Binx believes in anything? It's clear that he has no strong belief in religion, but what does he believe then? I like the Chesterton quote "when a man stops believing in God, he will believe in anything at all". Do you think Binx "believes in anything at all"? Or does he have more of a concrete belief in something?

    ReplyDelete
  2. This blog post brings to light some similarities between Binx and Charles from "Brideshead Revisited." A theme of Brideshead revisited was understanding how the characters grow through a search for more meaning in life. At first they seek fulfillment through material things, but slowly begin to realize that this is not giving them the desired result. They may not know that God is essentially calling them, and this may be Binx's situation. He is searching for something more meaningful, but he just doesn't know exactly what yet.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Personally, I do not think Binx believes in any higher power. In part three I think Binx only believes in existence. Binx only lives to fulfill his personal desires. Binx has a lucrative stock broker job but he doesn't give back to the community. He fulfills his personal desires with his secretaries. His family pressures him to go to medical school to make a difference in the world and seek religion. Binx ignores these pressures and is content with his current existence.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree, Binx and Charles share several similarities with their searches for purpose. However, Binx and Charles are in different stages of life. Charles is a young college student who becomes enthralled with Sebastian's immense wealth. Binx has seen combat and graduated from college. Originally, Charles believes wealth is the purpose for life. Binx differs from Charles because he is wealthy yet continues to search for purpose.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I believe that the stories of Binx and Charles illustrate a juxtaposition of ideals. Going off what Sean said, I believe that their struggles were essentially opposite with a common center: searching for purpose. Binx has everything he could want, however he needs more substance, whereas charles is moving towards the more glamorous things in life. One similarity between the two, however, is their family problems. Perhaps the reason both of these characters had an inability to feel content in their current lives had something to do with their broken relationships; For example, Charles' poor relationship with his father and Binx's not-so-close relationship with his mother.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think the characters family relationships play a significant role in each characters search. Charles cannot find purpose at home. He has awkward conversations with his father and there is no wealth or excitement. While at Brideshead, Charles experiences a different world that what he is accustomed. This new lifestyle thrills Charles and he thinks wealth accumulation is the purpose of life. If Charles had a stronger relationship with his father he would not feel the need or desire to leave him. Like Charles, Binx also is disillusioned from his family. His father is dead and his mother is remarried with a new family. Binx does not find solace in his family which makes him feel lonely and initially he only lives for himself (fulfilling his own desires).

    ReplyDelete
  7. I think that by the end of the novel Binx believes in something, even if it's not the articulated belief structure of the Catholic Church. Perhaps he comes to see the power of love or the gift of life, as evidenced by getting together with Kate at the end or how he devotes a little extra time to his family. To me, even if he doesn't express it that way, these are tiny mirrors of God's love for us. So whether or not he realizes it, he's participating in Christianity, whether or not he'd ever come to recognize it as such.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes I agree, I feel like Binx has to believe in something at the end. He does not seem so lost like he does in the beginning. Almost like he has a purpose and to me that comes with a belief in something.

      Delete
  8. I agree as well that Binx has to believe in something. It seems at the end his quest is over. Perhaps this is because he has found love in his relationship with Kate. As was mentioned in class, this love for Kate, much like Charles' love for Julia, allows both Charles and Binx to consider converting in the end. Granted, that would be a stretch to say that Binx did convert or was considering converting, but the pattern that comes up in many of the stories that we have read this term is that earthly love leads to divine love. Maybe that is why Binx no longer feels to lost or that everything is meaningless. I would like to think that he has considered converting, but one cannot really tell from the ending of "The Moviegoer."

    ReplyDelete